Parks Avenue Pizza is a charming gem nestled in Winter Park, Florida, at 119 E Lyman Ave. A true mom-and-pop establishment, it captures the essence of authentic pizza-making with a warm, welcoming atmosphere. From the moment you step inside, you can feel the dedication to quality and customer service that the owners consistently deliver. Their contact number, +1 407-599-9199, is just a dial away for any inquiries or orders.

The star of the show, of course, is the pizza. Customers rave about the light, crunchy dough that has zero flop, allowing the toppings to shine without overwhelming the palate. Reviewers, such as Michael Nguyen, praise the superb balance of tangy tomato sauce and delicious toppings, a testament to the care that goes into each pie. Whether it's a classic cheese or a gourmet selection, the pizza embodies New York-style flavors that have left many longing for a return visit.

But Park Avenue Pizza is more than just pizzas. Their menu offers a variety of cold subs, salads, and gourmet entrees that satisfy a wide range of cravings. From the Chicken Cutlet Sub to the Greek Salad, each dish is prepared with the same emphasis on fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The Eggplant Rollatini, for instance, is a comforting dish filled with ricotta and mozzarella, perfectly enveloped in marinara sauce—a delightful choice for any pasta lover.

Customer experiences further enhance the allure of Park Avenue Pizza. Diners share heartfelt stories of discovering this local treasure, especially after challenging times, like the recovery following Hurricane Ian. Jaciely Cartagena reflects on the joy of finding a hot meal post-storm, a sentiment echoed by many loyal patrons who appreciate the warmth of their service. Friendly staff members, like Kim, ensure that every customer feels valued, crafting memorable experiences along with their food.

With its perfect blend of quality food, community spirit, and attentive service, Park Avenue Pizza is more than just a pizza joint; it’s a beloved gathering spot. Whether you're planning a party or simply seeking a quick bite that feels like home, this eatery should be at the top of your must-visit list in Winter Park. Don’t let the opportunity to indulge in their fantastic flavors slip by—you'll likely find yourself returning again and again!